Should the Giants bring back Odell Beckham Jr?

Should the Giants bring back Odell Beckham Jr?

  • Yes

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • No

    Votes: 3 60.0%
  • Don't Know

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Depends

    Votes: 1 20.0%

  • Total voters
    5

Patricia Traina

Administrator
Staff member
Odell Beckham Jr's time has come to an end with the Cleveland Browns. Now that he's about to hit the waiver wire, should the Giants look to bring him back? Why or why not? Vote and then weigh in with your thoughts!
 
When he first came to the Giants OBJ could blow the top off any defense. He was a generational talent who made catches most excellent wide receivers could only dream of. Would I like to see him comeback. Part of me says yes, but then reality sets in. Several reason I doubt he will be back. It didn't end well in NY. It didn't work in Cleveland. He's coming off an ACL injury from last year. The Giants don't have any cap space this year or next year. Therefore I highly doubt he comes back but you never know.
 
Last edited:

Jerry329

Practice Squadder
He's clearly a lesser version of OBJ than the one who.excited us and he's clearly an immature young man. But we currently are short quality wide receivers. I don't doubt he'd be better than Sills, Johnson and probably Pettis. At the right (low) price, I would sign him
 

Patricia Traina

Administrator
Staff member
He's clearly a lesser version of OBJ than the one who.excited us and he's clearly an immature young man. But we currently are short quality wide receivers. I don't doubt he'd be better than Sills, Johnson and probably Pettis. At the right (low) price, I would sign him
No thanks. They don't need that drama. Twice now Odell has bitched about his lack of targets. A leopard can't change its spots, and there's no way they bring in that big of a personality into this locker room to potentially risk undermining Jones.
 
No thanks. They don't need that drama. Twice now Odell has bitched about his lack of targets. A leopard can't change its spots, and there's no way they bring in that big of a personality into this locker room to potentially risk undermining Jones.
Your so right. Talking about drama, how about the boat trip before a playoff game. He and the receivers dropped more then a few passes which could have gone for touch downs in the 1st quarter of that game.

Does anyone know what happens to his contract? If a team signs him do they pick up the remaining money on his original Giants contract?
 

Patricia Traina

Administrator
Staff member
Your so right. Talking about drama, how about the boat trip before a playoff game. He and the receivers dropped more then a few passes which could have gone for touch downs in the 1st quarter of that game.

Does anyone know what happens to his contract? If a team signs him do they pick up the remaining money on his original Giants contract?
If he's claimed off waivers, the new team inherits his existing contract. If not, then a new team enters into a new contract with him.
 
This roster is so inferior, they should take a chance on Beckham, although I question whether the coaches will know how to best use him, since they haven't yet figured out how to use Toney or Engram.
 

Patricia Traina

Administrator
Staff member
This roster is so inferior, they should take a chance on Beckham, although I question whether the coaches will know how to best use him, since they haven't yet figured out how to use Toney or Engram.
Absolutely not. You really want a guy who has now forced his way off two teams back on a team that's a mess?
 
Top